Belfast’s Smithfield Market so dirty it ‘looks derelict’, traders say

London, United Kingdom Jul 12, 2026 ALN: Traders at Smithfield Market in Belfast have raised serious concerns about the dilapidated condition of the historic shopping arcade, describing it as a "forgotten part of the city" that has fallen into disrepair. The market, located on Winetavern Street behind the bustling CastleCourt shopping centre, has served as a vibrant hub for local commerce and community for decades, yet many believe it now appears more like a relic of the past.

Smithfield Market has a long history in Belfast, having been established in the 19th century. Originally a thriving marketplace, it was known for its eclectic mix of stalls selling everything from fresh produce to antiques. Over the years, it has become a place where locals could find unique items, fostering a sense of community and nostalgia. However, recent reports from traders indicate that the market is now plagued by issues of cleanliness, safety, and maintenance.

Ryan Gilmore, the owner of NI Classico, has operated his business in Smithfield since 2019. He expressed frustration over the lack of response from the local council regarding concerns about the state of the building. "We keep our shops clean, tidy, presentable and safe for customers to come into. That’s what we should expect from the council when it comes to the building, but that’s not the case," he stated. Gilmore noted that the market's exterior is marred by layers of dirt, peeling paint, and a leaking roof, which has persisted despite previous repairs. The inadequate lighting and heating further exacerbate the uncomfortable conditions for both traders and customers.

Traders fear that the council's inaction may indicate a desire to neglect the site to the point of demolition rather than invest in its upkeep. James Gilliland, who has worked in a toy shop within the market for 24 years, voiced his concerns regarding fire safety protocols. He highlighted that vendors have not been provided with essential fire safety documentation, which is critical for ensuring a safe environment. Gilliland recounted a recent incident where he experienced a small electrical fire in his shop. Upon reporting the incident to the council, he felt that his concerns were dismissed, leading to the intervention of the fire brigade, who conducted a full fire safety survey. "They were asking me questions about paperwork that I don’t have, but that the council should have. They still haven’t provided it," he lamented.

The sentiment among traders reflects a broader issue of neglect that has plagued Smithfield Market in recent years. Many long-time customers and local residents share a sense of nostalgia for the market, recalling fond memories of browsing stalls filled with toys, comics, records, and collectibles. East Belfast councillor Brian Smyth, who has personal memories of visiting the market during his childhood, expressed concern over its current state. "It feels like nothing has changed. It’s stuck in time. You can see the deterioration. It’s not clean. It’s dirty, grim. Long term, where are we with this? It’s the forgotten part of the city centre," he remarked. Smyth emphasized the need for local councillors to take a more active interest in revitalizing the area and addressing the concerns raised by traders.

The implications of the current state of Smithfield Market extend beyond aesthetics; they touch on issues of urban development, community engagement, and local heritage. The market is not only a commercial space but also a cultural landmark that contributes to the identity of Belfast. Its decline could signify a loss of local history and community spirit, as well as a potential impact on the local economy. Traders argue that a cleaner, safer, and more inviting market could attract more visitors, benefiting both the businesses within the market and the surrounding area.

In response to the concerns raised by traders, Belfast City Council has acknowledged the feedback and expressed a commitment to Smithfield Market as a vital part of the city’s retail heritage. A spokesperson for the council stated, "Belfast City Council remains committed to Smithfield Market, which is an asset in our city’s retail heritage. Our markets team maintains regular, active engagement with Smithfield traders. We take all feedback from our tenants seriously and use it to guide our ongoing improvements." The council indicated that maintenance teams are currently addressing immediate issues, such as external weeding, deep cleaning, and structural upkeep, and emphasized the importance of partnership with the traders.

While the council's response suggests a willingness to engage with the traders and address their concerns, the effectiveness of these efforts remains to be seen. The traders at Smithfield Market are hopeful that their voices will be heard and that meaningful action will be taken to restore the market to its former glory. The ongoing dialogue between the council and the traders will be crucial in determining the future of Smithfield Market and its place within the broader context of Belfast's urban landscape.

As Belfast continues to evolve, the fate of Smithfield Market may serve as a barometer for the city's approach to heritage preservation and community engagement. The outcome of this situation could influence not only the market itself but also the strategies employed by the council in managing other historical sites throughout the city. The need for investment in maintenance and restoration of such sites is evident, as they play a significant role in fostering local culture and economic activity.

In conclusion, the plight of Smithfield Market highlights the challenges faced by historic marketplaces in urban settings, where the pressures of modernization and neglect can threaten their existence. The voices of traders and local residents are vital in advocating for the preservation of such spaces, ensuring that they remain vibrant centers of community life for future generations. The coming months will determine whether the council's commitment translates into tangible improvements, revitalizing Smithfield Market and restoring it as a cherished landmark in Belfast's cityscape.